It would indeed be a puzzling move for the Colts to draft a quarterback within the first three rounds, especially considering their investment in Veteran QB Star. Given his raw talent and the team’s commitment to his development, using high draft capital on another QB would send mixed signals about their confidence in him.
While adding a late-round developmental quarterback or a veteran backup makes sense, spending a premium pick on one would create unnecessary controversy and potentially stunt Richardson’s growth. The Colts have other pressing needs—such as bolstering their offensive line, improving the secondary, and adding more playmakers—that should take priority.
Do you think Ballard might still consider it as an insurance policy, or is this all just draft speculation?
Who might the Colts target if they draft a quarterback in the first three rounds?
Indianapolis holds the 14th overall pick, which likely takes them out of the running for Miami’s Cam Ward or Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders, both projected to be top-five selections. Ward is a potential No. 1 pick for the Tennessee Titans, while Sanders could land with the New York Giants at No. 3.
However, in the second or third round, the Colts could look at options like Ole Miss’ Jaxson Dart, Alabama’s Jalen Milroe, or Texas’ Quinn Ewers. Although none of them are expected to go in the first round, they could still push Anthony Richardson for the starting role in 2025. After all, history has shown that quarterbacks don’t need to be first-round picks to make a significant impact.
Would Drafting a Quarterback Early Be a Mistake?
Since being selected by the Colts in 2023, Anthony Richardson’s career in Indianapolis has been underwhelming. He has struggled with injuries and accuracy, completing less than 48 percent of his passes last season. Despite these challenges, Richardson still has the potential to develop into a star in the future.