When the Cincinnati Reds promoted Sal Stewart to the big leagues, fans were instantly energized — and Stewart delivered right away. In his MLB debut, the 21-year-old picked up his first hit, going 1-for-3 at the plate. Not bad for a former first-round pick from 2022.
Cincinnati has a history of developing great talent only to let it walk away when the price tag gets too high. But with a promising core of young players and a farm system producing steady talent, the Reds now have a chance to break that pattern — and Stewart might be the key.
It’s time for the Reds to lock Stewart into a long-term deal.
Across the league, smart teams are securing young stars early in their careers — often during their pre-arbitration years — to avoid future contract headaches and rising market prices. These early extensions give players financial security while giving teams cost certainty and long-term value.
Stewart fits that profile perfectly. He’s been a force in the minors, and scouts believe he can anchor the middle of the Reds’ lineup for years. He also embodies everything Reds fans love: youth, talent, and work ethic.
If the front office waits too long, they risk repeating a familiar mistake. Just look at Elly De La Cruz — his meteoric rise has likely put him out of reach financially for a small-market team. Stewart could follow a similar path if the Reds don’t act soon.
The current market suggests Stewart’s extension could fall between Lawrence Butler’s 7-year, \$65 million deal (roughly \$9.3M/year) and Roman Anthony’s 8-year, \$130 million deal (about \$16.2M/year). Cincinnati doesn’t have to spend top dollar — but acting now could secure Stewart at a manageable cost while keeping him through his prime.
Some players just have “it” — the skill, charisma, and connection with fans that can transform a franchise. Stewart seems like one of those rare players. If the Reds truly want to build lasting success, they need to move quickly. Sign him, build around him, and finally rewrite the narrative that has plagued this team for far too long.