The New York Yankees, in their urgent search for experienced starting pitchers, end up sending a top prospect down despite his strong spring showing?
The Yankees’ starting rotation has been severely impacted by injuries, with at least two of their projected starters sidelined for much—if not all—of the season. This has put their depth to the test as they attempt to defend their American League title.
The competition for the final rotation spots may come down to Will Warren—ranked as the Yankees’ No. 5 prospect, boasting a 2.87 ERA with 16 strikeouts in 15.2 innings this spring—and veteran right-hander Carlos Carrasco, a 38-year-old non-roster invitee signed to a minor league deal. Since Carrasco’s contract includes an opt-out clause if he isn’t added to the active roster, some within the Yankees organization believe the team might retain him to avoid losing a much-needed arm.
“The Yankees need Carlos Carrasco right now simply because they don’t have many healthy starting pitchers on the roster,” said Alex Wilson of the Empire Sports Network podcast Fireside Yankees.
Injuries Take a Toll on Yankees’ Once-Elite Rotation
The Yankees entered the season with what was considered one of MLB’s strongest rotations, but that depth has quickly eroded.
In early March, reigning American League Rookie of the Year Luis Gil was diagnosed with a high-grade lat strain, shutting him down from throwing for at least six weeks before re-evaluation.
Just a week later, ace Gerrit Cole underwent tests on his sore elbow, ultimately requiring Tommy John surgery, which will keep him out for the entire 2025 season.
Most recently, Clarke Schmidt was scratched from his scheduled start due to shoulder soreness. Instead, he threw a 24-pitch bullpen session Monday morning and later reported feeling fine.
“I was bouncing back a little slower this week, so we’re just being cautious given the time of year,” Schmidt explained. “With a couple of guys already out of the rotation, you don’t want a minor issue to become a bigger one. Just being smart, and I felt really good today.”
Now, the Yankees will monitor Schmidt’s recovery closely.
“I think we feel good about it, but any time a pitcher gets scratched, there’s always some concern,” manager Aaron Boone admitted. “Especially with everything we’ve already dealt with this spring. Hopefully, we’re in the clear.”