The Chicago Cubs have emerged as serious contenders in the NL Central, bolstered by an offseason that landed star outfielder Kyle Tucker. However, a glaring weakness remains in their infield—particularly at third base. As the Cubs seek to round out their roster for a potential postseason run, a prime opportunity has emerged: a trade for St. Louis Cardinals’ third baseman Nolan Arenado.
Why Arenado to the Cubs Works
Despite the Cardinals being close to the top of the standings, they’re grappling with an aging core and future roster concerns. Arenado, a 10-time Gold Glove winner still performing at an elite level (.316 AVG with power), remains a trade candidate largely due to his hefty contract—\$74 million over the next three seasons—and St. Louis’s need to get younger. His no-trade clause complicates things, but Arenado has shown openness to joining a contender.
For the Cubs, Arenado fills a major hole. His addition would instantly upgrade Chicago’s infield defense and add a consistent offensive presence. Combining him with Dansby Swanson and Nico Hoerner could create the league’s top defensive infield, and his bat would enhance a lineup already featuring Tucker, Seiya Suzuki, and Cody Bellinger. With Chicago eager to win now and willing to deal prospects, the timing feels right.
St. Louis, on the other hand, may benefit from retooling. Trading Arenado, though difficult—especially within the division—could help replenish their farm system and offer financial relief. If Arenado waives his no-trade clause and the Cardinals are open to the deal, the opportunity is there.
The Trade Details
Cubs Receive:
Nolan Arenado
Cardinals Receive:
James Triantos (3B prospect)
Cade Horton (RHP prospect)
Kevin Alcántara (OF prospect)
\$20 million sent to Cubs to help cover Arenado’s salary
Why It Works for Both Sides
Triantos is a promising third baseman with developing power and defense. Horton boasts top-end starter potential with a mid-90s fastball. Alcántara is a high-upside outfielder with elite tools. This trio would inject much-needed youth and talent into the Cardinals’ system. The added cash makes the financial side more manageable for Chicago.
For the Cubs, it’s a clear “win-now” strategy. Arenado offers defensive stability, a strong bat, and postseason experience—an ideal fit for a team chasing a title. Though the cost in prospects is significant, the Cubs’ depth allows them to absorb the hit.
For the Cardinals, it’s about positioning for long-term success. Shedding Arenado’s salary and acquiring top-tier young talent helps them move toward their next competitive window.
This proposed deal could be a defining moment in the NL Central, giving the Cubs a final piece for a title push and offering the Cardinals a path toward a brighter future.